People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I was there my 1st time & it won’t be my last !!! The pizza was amazing it gaved me like an old taste of the old Pizza Hut slices they use to have !!! I had chicken buffalo and ai love a lil crunch on my pizza so it was amazing & my mom had a plain slice. We will definitely be back again & the girl that took out order was also nice & friendly. Thank You!!! ”
“ The chef Jose is amazing, literally the best food we've had in a very long time ”
“ Siena’s Pizza is a small spot, but I really liked the open kitchen setup—you can see them making the pizza, which is a nice touch. I was a little hesitant to order after reading some mixed reviews, but I decided to give it a shot. I placed a phone order for pickup, and the lady on the phone was really sweet and patient, making sure everything was correct. She told me the order would be ready in 25 minutes, and when I arrived after 35 minutes, it was already waiting for me—perfect timing. The prices are reasonable, and the food did not disappoint. The pizza was excellent, definitely one of the best around. I also ordered wings, asking for them well done, and they were cooked perfectly—crispy and flavorful. The cheesesteak, however, was just okay; the bread wasn’t great, which took away from the experience. Overall, I’ll definitely be coming back for the pizza and wings. If you’re in Monticello and craving a solid slice, Siena’s is worth a try! ”
“ Best Pizza in Monticello!! Wings and Dinners are top-notch too, as is their service - and they deliver! ”
“ I must say I was impressed with the quality of pizza this business has first time there yesterday came up to visit family and thought I order a large pizza it was delicious. Keep up the good work. I recommend this place to others. Will see you next weekend again! ”
“ Best pizza around this area. We always get the Buffalo chicken pie. It’s fire. You guys do such a great job! Thank you. Wanted to show yall some love. Always fresh and delicious. ”
“ Food was delicious. They were very timely with their delivery. Overall, very happy ! ”
“ Delicious food and friendly service! We loved the chicken roll and were really impressed by the lovely presentation of the mozzarella caprese appetizer which we also enjoyed. ”
About
Siena's Pizza
Welcome to the delightful world of Siena's Pizza, nestled in the heart of Monticello, NY, at 321 Broadway. This local gem has quickly garnered a loyal following, cherished for its exceptional pizza and warm, friendly atmosphere. With a phone number always at your service (+1 845-791-7662), it’s clear that Siena's Pizza is aimed at making your dining experience memorable.
What sets Siena's Pizza apart? According to patrons, it is not merely the delicious offerings but the inviting ambiance as well. The open kitchen setup draws customers in, allowing them to witness the magic of pizza-making firsthand. This element adds a layer of engagement, making each visit a real treat.
- Outstanding Pizza: Guests rave about the remarkable flavors reminiscent of classic pizza experiences. One customer notably expressed, "The pizza was amazing; it gave me the old taste of the Pizza Hut slices they used to have!" Highlights include the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, which has received high praise for its perfect crunch.
- Cordial Service: The staff at Siena's Pizza are equally impressive. Multiple guests commend the friendly demeanor of the team, from taking orders over the phone to serving up smiles as pizza is delivered. One review highlighted how an order was handled with sweet patience, ensuring nothing was overlooked.
- Variety and Quality: Beyond pizza, Siena's offers an array of options such as wings and dinners. Reviewers have noted the wings are "crispy and flavorful," complementing the pizza perfectly. While some dishes, like the cheesesteak, may leave room for improvement, the pizza remains the shining star.
Siena's Pizza not only values taste but also community, making each visitor feel at home. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this establishment is a must-visit for anyone craving a satisfying slice. The delicious food, reasonable prices, and welcoming environment ensure that your visit will leave you wanting to return.
So, the next time you find yourself in Monticello, make sure to stop by Siena's Pizza—where fantastic food, friendly faces, and a nostalgic pizza experience await!
Book a table